New: The $100M AI Visibility Roadmap, built from 7,960 live pages and 197 A/B tests. Get it free →

Home / Blog / Shopify CRO Checklist, Ranked by Real Test Results

CRO · 10 min read

Shopify CRO Checklist, Ranked by Real Test Results

Most CRO checklists treat every item as equal. This one ranks each item by the A/B test record behind it, so you know what to do first and what to test before you trust.

Robert Battle ·

Key takeaways
  • Rank CRO checklist items by evidence: proven repeat winners first, checkout fixes second, and mixed-record ideas only as tests.
  • An FAQ accordion won 8 of 8 homepage tests and 19 of 19 FAQ section tests in QCK's data.
  • Review stars placement is the most-repeated product page winner: 9 tests with an 89% win rate.
  • Extra costs are the top stated reason for abandoning checkout (40% in Baymard's survey), so show shipping and fees before checkout.
  • Colors, grid layouts and trust badges had mixed or small records, so never ship them without a test.

The best Shopify CRO checklist is ordered by evidence, not by where an item sits on the page. Start with the changes that have won real A/B tests most often: an FAQ accordion on the homepage and top collections, review stars near the product title, a second image carousel on product pages and a cleaner cart drawer. Then fix the checkout problems shoppers report most, and test everything else.

This checklist is for Shopify and e-commerce teams who have seen the 100-point CRO checklists and do not know where to start. Every item below is ranked by the record behind it, using 197 A/B tests QCK ran across 26 e-commerce stores and published checkout research from the Baymard Institute. You'll get the ranked list, the evidence for each item, the items you should test before trusting, and a way to work through it in 30 days.

How this CRO checklist is ranked

Most ecommerce CRO checklists are sorted by page: homepage, collection, product, cart. That is tidy, but it treats every item as equal. A new button color and a product FAQ get the same checkbox, even though one of them has a far better record than the other.

This checklist uses three tiers instead.

TierWhat it meansEvidenceWhat to do
1. Proven repeat winnersWon on store after store5 or more QCK tests with a win rate of 85% or higherDo these first, and still test them
2. Checkout fixes shoppers ask forRemoves a stated reason for abandoningBaymard Institute survey of US shoppersFix what applies to your store
3. Test before you trustMixed or small test recordsFewer than 5 tests, or a win rate below 85%Never ship without a test

The QCK numbers come from our published A/B test results: 197 tests, 171 wins (an 86.8% win rate) and an average lift of 12.8% per test. A test only counts as a win when the new version made more money than the original. The full breakdown is in our study of all 197 tests.

The Shopify CRO checklist at a glance

Here is the whole list in ranked order. The sections below explain each item and the evidence behind it.

#Checklist itemPageEvidence
1Add an FAQ accordion to the homepageHomepage8 tests, 100% win rate
2Move review stars near the product titleProduct9 tests, 89% win rate
3Add an FAQ accordion to top collectionsCollections7 tests, 86% win rate
4Add an image carousel below the main product imageProduct5 of 5 wins
5Redesign the cart drawerCart6 of 7 wins
6Show all costs before checkoutCart and checkout40% of abandoners cite extra costs (Baymard)
7Allow guest checkout and shorten the formCheckout18% cite forced accounts, 17% a long checkout (Baymard)
8Test menus, trust badges, colors and grid layoutSitewideMixed or small records

Tier 1: the proven repeat winners

These five items have the strongest records in our data. Each one ran at least five times, on different stores, and won at least 85% of the time.

Win rate of the most-repeated test on each page typeNumber of tests shown in each label
FAQ accordion, FAQ sections (19 tests)100%
FAQ accordion, homepage (8 tests)100%
Review stars placement, product pages (9 tests)89%
FAQ accordion, collections (7 tests)86%
Button and CTA color, sitewide (18 tests)83%
View the data
Value
FAQ accordion, FAQ sections (19 tests)100%
FAQ accordion, homepage (8 tests)100%
Review stars placement, product pages (9 tests)89%
FAQ accordion, collections (7 tests)86%
Button and CTA color, sitewide (18 tests)83%

Source: QCK A/B test results, 197 tests, qck.co/ab-test-results

1. Add an FAQ accordion to the homepage

This is the most reliable change we have tested. On homepages it ran 8 times and won all 8. Counting every FAQ section test, the record is 19 wins in 19 tests with an average lift of 11.7%.

  • Place 4 to 8 questions in a collapsed accordion, below your main products or collections.
  • Use the questions your support inbox gets most: shipping time, returns, sizing, ingredients or materials, and guarantees.
  • Keep answers to two or three sentences, and link to the full policy page.

2. Move review stars near the product title

Review stars placement is the most-repeated winner on product pages: 9 tests with an 89% win rate. Many themes show reviews only at the bottom of the page, where most shoppers never scroll.

  • Show the star rating and review count directly under the product title.
  • Make the stars a link that jumps to the full reviews section.
  • Check it on mobile first. The stars should be visible without scrolling.

3. Add an FAQ accordion to your top collections

On collection pages the FAQ accordion ran 7 times and won 86% of the time. Collections are the hardest page type to win on in our data (an 81.0% win rate overall), so a change with this record is worth doing early.

  • Put the accordion below the product grid, so it does not push products down.
  • Answer category questions, such as how to choose between products, and repeat your shipping and returns basics.

4. Add an image carousel below the main product image

A second carousel under the main product image won 5 of 5 tests. Our read is that shoppers who ignore small thumbnails still swipe a large, obvious carousel. Fill it with lifestyle shots, close-ups, scale shots and images that answer common questions.

5. Redesign the cart drawer

Cart drawer redesigns won 6 of 7 tests. The cart is where shoppers check what they are paying, so clarity matters more than decoration.

  • Show the product image, variant, quantity and price clearly.
  • Show the shipping cost or the free shipping threshold, and how far the shopper is from it.
  • Make the checkout button the most obvious thing in the drawer.
Get this checklist ranked for your store

We review your highest-traffic pages and show which checklist items are most likely to win on your store, with prioritized fixes and the revenue math.

Get my test plan →

Tier 2: the checkout checklist

QCK's repeat-winner data covers the storefront. For checkout, the best public evidence is the Baymard Institute's cart abandonment research. Baymard calculates an average cart abandonment rate of 70.22% from 50 published studies. In its survey of US online shoppers, 42% said they abandoned because they were just browsing. The chart shows the reasons the rest gave.

Why US shoppers abandon during checkoutExcludes the 42% who said they were just browsing; shoppers could pick several reasons
Extra costs too high40%
Delivery too slow20%
Did not trust site with card19%
Had to create an account18%
Checkout too long or complicated17%
Site errors or crashes17%
Returns policy not satisfactory13%
Could not see total cost up front12%
View the data
Value
Extra costs too high40%
Delivery too slow20%
Did not trust site with card19%
Had to create an account18%
Checkout too long or complicated17%
Site errors or crashes17%
Returns policy not satisfactory13%
Could not see total cost up front12%

Source: Baymard Institute, Cart Abandonment Rate Statistics (page last updated October 28, 2026)

Each reason maps to a checklist item.

Reason shoppers gaveShareChecklist item
Extra costs too high (shipping, tax, fees)40%Show shipping and fees on the product page and in the cart
Delivery was too slow20%State delivery times before checkout, and offer a faster option if you can
Did not trust the site with card details19%Offer familiar payment methods and keep checkout on your own domain and branding
Site wanted an account18%Allow guest checkout
Checkout too long or complicated17%Remove optional fields and steps
Website had errors or crashed17%Place a test order on mobile and desktop every month
Returns policy was not satisfactory13%Summarize returns in one line near the add to cart button
Could not see the total cost up front12%Show an order total, with shipping, in the cart

Baymard also estimates that the average large e-commerce site could gain a 35.26% increase in conversion rate through better checkout design. That figure is a potential for large sites based on Baymard's own testing, not a promise for any one store. The useful part is the direction: the biggest stated reason for abandoning is cost that appears late, and that is fixed on the product page and in the cart, not only in checkout.

Tier 3: test before you trust

These items appear on almost every CRO checklist. In our data their records are mixed or too small to rely on. Run them as tests, and be ready for a loss.

Checklist itemQCK recordHow to treat it
Menu reorder and restructure3 of 3Promising, small sample. Test it.
Trust badge placement on product pages2 of 3Test placement, and keep badges honest and few.
Button and CTA color18 tests, 83% win rateUsually wins, but below our overall 86.8%. Test it.
2 products per row on collections1 of 2A coin flip so far. Test on mobile.
CTA color in the homepage second section1 of 2A coin flip so far. Low priority.

Notice what sits in this tier: colors, layouts and badges. These are the changes teams argue about most, and they are the ones with the least certain records. Changes that add information a shopper needs, such as answers, reviews and images, did better than changes that restyle what is already there.

Foundation checks before you test anything

A test on a broken store measures the wrong thing. Run these checks first. They are not ranked by test results because they are requirements, not experiments.

Measurement

  • Shopify Analytics shows sessions, sessions with cart additions, sessions that reached checkout and sessions that completed checkout.
  • GA4 purchase tracking matches Shopify orders closely enough to trust.
  • You know your conversion rate and revenue per visitor by device and by traffic source. Our guide to the conversion rate metric covers the formulas.

Speed and mobile

  • Your product and collection templates pass Core Web Vitals: LCP within 2.5 seconds, INP within 200 milliseconds and CLS of 0.1 or less.
  • The add to cart button, price and variant picker are easy to tap on a phone.
  • Apps you no longer use are removed, along with their scripts.

Basics shoppers expect

  • Shipping cost, delivery time and returns policy are stated on the product page.
  • Search returns results for your top product names and common misspellings.
  • Out-of-stock variants are clearly marked.
Bring in shoppers who are ready to buy

The free $100M AI Visibility Roadmap is built from 7,960 live pages and 197 A/B tests. It covers getting cited by ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and Perplexity.

Get the free roadmap →

How to work through the checklist

Do not try to do everything at once. One change at a time is slower, but it is the only way to know what worked. Here is a 30-day plan.

  1. Days 1 to 3: run the foundation checks. Fix tracking gaps and anything broken. Record your baseline conversion rate and revenue per visitor by device.
  2. Days 4 to 5: find your biggest leak. Compare each funnel step to the one before it. A low add to cart rate points to product pages. A drop between cart and checkout points to the cart and costs.
  3. Day 6: pick one Tier 1 item for that page. Write a one-sentence hypothesis and what you expect to change.
  4. Days 7 to 10: build the variant. Change only one thing, and check it on mobile and desktop.
  5. Days 11 to 28: run the test. Split traffic evenly. Run it for full weeks so weekdays and weekends are both covered, and do not stop early because one version is ahead.
  6. Days 29 to 30: decide and record. Judge the result on revenue per visitor. Ship the winner, log the result either way, and pick the next item.

While the test runs, work through the Tier 2 checkout fixes that are plain errors, such as a missing returns line or an unclear shipping cost. Those do not need a test. If you are not sure which testing app to use, see our comparison of the best CRO tools for Shopify.

CRO checklist mistakes to avoid

  • Shipping the whole checklist at once. If you change ten things and revenue moves, you will not know which change did it, or whether one of them hurt.
  • Judging tests on clicks. A variant can get more add to carts and less revenue. Measure revenue per visitor.
  • Stopping a test early. Early leads often fade. Decide the run time before you start.
  • Skipping the log. Without a record of losses, teams re-run failed ideas a year later.
  • Copying another store's winner without testing. In our data about 13% of researched ideas still lost. Unresearched copies should be expected to do worse.
  • Starting with colors. Color and layout tests had the weakest records in our data. Start with information.

Start with one item this week

Pick the Tier 1 item that matches your biggest leak and test it. For most Shopify stores that means review stars near the product title or an FAQ accordion on the homepage. Both are small builds with strong records. Then keep going down the list, one test at a time, and keep your own record of what won.

If you would rather have a team run the list for you, QCK's Shopify CRO service builds and reports every test, losses included. You can also get a custom plan showing the first tests we would run on your store.

Want us to run the checklist for you?

Book a free 30-minute call. We benchmark you against your top three competitors and show the pages ready to move, with prioritized fixes.

Get my custom plan →
FAQ

Questions & answers

What is a CRO checklist?
A CRO checklist is a list of changes and checks meant to raise the share of visitors who buy. The useful ones rank items by evidence, so you start with the changes most likely to make more money.
What should be first on an ecommerce CRO checklist?
After confirming your tracking works, start with proven repeat winners. In QCK's 197 tests, an FAQ accordion on the homepage won 8 of 8 times and review stars placement on product pages won 89% of 9 tests.
How long does a CRO checklist take to complete?
Plan on one tested change every three to four weeks. A test should run for full weeks so weekdays and weekends are both covered, which means a checklist is a rolling program, not a weekend project.
Do I need to A/B test every checklist item?
Test anything that changes what shoppers see, because even strong ideas lose on some stores. Plain errors, such as a missing returns policy or a broken button, should just be fixed.
Is this checklist only for Shopify?
The test data comes from e-commerce stores and the steps reference Shopify features, but the ranking logic applies to any online store: add information where shoppers hesitate, remove surprise costs and test the rest.
Free custom plan

Find the revenue you're leaving on the table

A free 30-minute call where we build the first version of your plan with you. You leave with a plan either way.

  • Your score across Google, AI citations, branded demand, and reviews
  • The pages on your site that are ready to move right now
  • Your first Flagship page and the first three tests we'd run

Step 1 of 3

Get your free custom plan

Free. Takes about 30 seconds.